Lisa Rinna and Colton Underwood had unfinished business when the Traitors Season 4 cast reunited to film a reunion Thursday.
Sources told Page Six that Rinna, 62, confronted Underwood, 34, about her use of the word “hostage” during the season when discussing Rinna being a traitor.
Insiders say Rinna is an experienced “housewife” with a poisonous tongue who held Underwood to the fire a little unprepared.
Our sources claim the former “Bachelor” star stormed off the set in a fuss, but one source claims it was an upset exit that happened in tandem with a planned break.
He is said to have returned to the set after refilling himself with air and drinking water.
Representatives for Underwood, Rinna, and Peacock did not immediately respond to Page Six’s requests for comment.
During the season, which was still airing, Underwood, who played the game as Faithful, suspected Rinna of being a traitor and expressed his intention to take her “hostage”.
He pulled the “Real Housewives of Beverly Hills” alum aside and promised to protect her from being ostracized at the Round Table if she vowed not to have him “murdered.”
Rinna denies being a traitor and refuses to make a deal, leading Underwood to take the lead in ousting her. (Underwood was later “murdered” by other rebels.)
After the episode aired, Rinna wrote in the comments of the thread, “Let’s talk about you being a stalker…”
Before coming out as gay in April 2021, Underwood dated “The Bachelor” contestant Cassie Randolph from March 2019 to May 2020.
After their breakup, Randolph accused Underwood of stalking and harassing her.
She claimed that Underwood sent her “disturbing” text messages and placed a tracking device on her car.
Randolph was granted a temporary restraining order, but later requested it be revoked, and Underwood said at the time that she had addressed Randolph’s concerns and reached a private agreement.
“I wish I had had the courage to correct myself before I hurt anyone,” he previously said.
After Rinna’s “stalker” comments went viral, she asked fans on her Instagram Story to “please be gentle” with online comments as she was just playing the game in “housewife” mode.
“Please don’t send death threats or do anything that puts your family at risk,” she urged. Peacock also condemned “cyberbullying” and “personal attacks” in the statement.
