Hollywood insiders are taking sides in the ‘toxic’ conflict between Ashley Tisdale and her former A-list mom group!
Duff’s husband Matthew Koma appeared to slam Tisdale on social media after Tisdale broke ranks and denigrated the group, whose members include Hilary Duff, Mandy Moore and designer Sammy Ryan.
“Matthew gave her what she wanted,” a source familiar with the altercation told Page Six. The source went on to say of Tisdale, “She is intolerable,” adding that her breakup with her friend has been “a long time coming.”
Tisdale kicked off 2026 by slamming her former mom friend group as “toxic” in a candid essay for New York Magazine’s The Cut. In the article, Tisdale claimed that he was no longer able to attend Creaky Group events.
The former Disney star went on to recall that she “wasn’t cool enough” with the rest of the group, and that “one night, after putting[her]daughter to bed, she was sitting alone… completely at a loss as to whether[she]had done something ‘wrong’ to be left out.”
Eventually, she texted the group and wrote, “It’s too high school for me and I don’t want to participate anymore.”
Tisdale did not give her name, but social media sleuths noticed that she had unfollowed Duff, 38, and Mandy Moore, 40.
Duff’s husband appeared to acknowledge his wife’s membership in the group when he mocked The Cut’s essay on Tuesday.
Koma posted a mock-up of her own cover with the caption, “Mom’s Group Tells Everything Through Dad’s Eyes: When You’re the Most Self-centered Toneless on Earth, Other Mothers Tend to Shift Their Focus to Your Actual Toddler.”
He captioned the post: “Read our new interview with @thecut.”
Koma did not address Tisdale directly, but sources said his messages referred to her.
Ryan also seemed to allude to Tisdale’s work by posting a clip of someone lip-syncing to Megan Thee Stallion’s “Hair,” with lyrics like “I don’t care if these bitches don’t like me ’cause I’m pretty as fuck.” subtle!
Ryan captioned it all as, “Feeling like 2026.”
Duff’s sister Hayley actually liked Tisdale’s essay and appeared to take her sister’s side.
Comedian Chelsea Handler also weighed in on the supposed scandal.
In an interview with Page Six Radio on Wednesday, she defended her “wonderful and kind” friend Moore.
“I don’t know what happened, but I know Mandy Moore and she’s a wonderful, kind person,” Handler said. “So let me just say this: I don’t know much about Ashley Tisdale,” she added.
Representatives for Duff and Tisdale could not be reached.
