Matt Kalil is unlikely to win his legal battle with ex-wife Haley Bailey over comments she made about the size of his penis, legal experts say.
“There is zero chance this case will go to trial. It will either be dismissed or settled,” Los Angeles-based attorney Gregory Doll told Page Six. “That’s going to be difficult.”
As for Khalil’s privacy claims, Dole said they “probably meet the elements of the allegations,” but that the two are “public figures,” even though the former NFL player claims in his lawsuit that he has retired from public life.
“There will be First Amendment questions regarding Ms. Haley’s ability to publicly discuss her sex life,” said Dole, a partner at Dole, Amir & Ely. “She’s not the first celebrity to do something like this, and there’s no clear rule that the subject is off-limits.”
As for his unjust enrichment claim, his lawyers say the judge will decide whether she is “taking financial advantage of the story and whether he should receive a portion of that money.”
“The complaint states that she has over 30 million followers on various social media platforms and has received numerous recognitions as a content creator,” Dole explained. “Perhaps this article may have increased her following, but ironically his lawsuit will probably double or triple that number.”
Dole went on to discuss Khalil’s potential “motives,” saying, “He’s married to a social media influencer with a large audience, he’s remarried, he has a young child, and I can understand the idea that he might not want her to talk about his anatomy in public.”
“However, if protecting privacy is the primary concern, the normal step would be to send a cease and desist letter,” he added. “Then would you consider filing a lawsuit only if she continues to talk about the topic after receiving the letter?”
The complaint does not say whether Mr. Bailey was served with a cease-and-desist letter.
Beverly Hills defense attorney Adam Michael Sacks agreed, explaining, “I don’t think he has much of a case. He’s a public figure, and just because he’s retired doesn’t mean he’s not a public figure anymore.”
“This case won’t last long.”
A representative for Bailey did not immediately respond to Page Six’s request for comment.
In a November 2025 Twitch stream, Bayley claimed that their 2022 divorce was because of Khalil’s penis size.
“We were trying to make it (our marriage) work,” she told popular streamer Marlon.
“It’s crap… It’s crap for our whole marriage,” Bailey added. “But I was willing to try everything. I tried all the therapists, I tried all the doctors. I’m not going to lie…I looked up the lipotype ST…so it’s kind of funny. My life is like a comedy, it kind of writes itself. That was the biggest factor.”
The model claimed that Khalil’s penis is “the size of two Coke cans stacked on top of each other, maybe a third of the size.”
She concluded: “We tried, but it’s not possible unless you shed a tear.”
Khalil remained silent until filing the lawsuit on Tuesday.
In a court filing obtained by Page Six, he claimed that her “degrading and highly personal comments” caused “unwanted public attention and invasive comments.”
Family members of the former Minnesota Vikings player were also said to have been negatively affected, including his wife Keilani Asmus, who said she received “disturbing” and “alarming” messages.
“Defendant shared sensitive personal information about Plaintiff for the entertainment of her viewers and for her own financial benefit, even though Plaintiff reasonably expected it to remain private,” the complaint states. “Defendant’s choice to discuss such a personal matter that is not of legitimate public concern was extreme, outrageous, and beyond the bounds of common sense.”
He claimed he had suffered “severe emotional distress, humiliation, reputational damage, and emotional distress.”
Khalil is seeking $75,000 in damages.
Bailey has not yet responded to the lawsuit, but the model told Page Six in a statement: “The truth is in the original livestream, which is still live on Marlon’s YouTube account. I appreciate him in so many ways through that conversation.”
“I am truly shocked and incredibly hurt to hear the news of this application,” she continued. “Litigation is a harrowing and emotionally draining experience, and I am heartbroken that he chose to subject us and our families to this ordeal.”
“Haley Kalil exposed personal and intimate details about Matt Kalil that were of no legitimate public interest, exposing Matt Kalil and his family to widespread ridicule and unwanted attention,” Ryan Sabah, the player’s attorney, responded in a statement to Page Six.
The lawyer added: “Haley Khalil shared sensitive personal information about her ex-husband in an apparent pursuit of wealth and fame.
“Her actions were extreme and outrageous, beyond the bounds of decency, and caused significant harm to Matt Kalil, his family, and his business.”
Khalil and Bailey married in 2015, but seven years later she filed for divorce, citing “irreconcilable differences.”
